I have them all. And you do get a second Christmas Tree, unlike the not getting of a second Elf Hat, Santa Hat, Candy Cane Sword or Reindeer Pet.

But interestingly enough, if you previously had them from last year, the number of CI's as told in your Profile does increase by the ones above that are CI's.

This could be the reason that my Profile is 12 or more higher than my extensive record keeping or simple counting of Hats, Capes, Glasses, Belts and House items both unplaced and those in the 4 parts of the house.

Except the discrepancy had started to become apparent as early as June or perhaps earlier. That's before the game was a year old. And other than Christmas, there had not been any events where you are told you are going to get something that you already have. So I'm still at a loss for understanding this.

Plus I got the polka dot cape during Easter and it does not appear in my inventory. Does ANYONE have it?

I was thinking that there might be a hanukah thing tonight based on what the Rabbi seemed to be saying...